How Decision Fatigue Sabotages Success at Work (and How to Beat It)

Why Decision Fatigue Threatens Leadership

Every day, the average adult makes approximately 35,000 decisions.

For professional leaders, some of these decisions carry expensive consequences.

Whether it a be a strategic choice or high-level leadership decision, decision fatigue is a threat.

As mental energy wanes, decision overload drives individuals to rely on cognitive shortcuts, make impulsive choices, or experience debilitating indecision.

The ripple effect hits far beyond you.

Poor decision-making—as a consequence of decision exhaustion—disrupts teams, derails critical projects, and undermines strategic goals.

And this damages team moral.

It brings indecision into play, shrinking the one attribute every colleague wants from their leader; decisiveness.

‍

Recognising the Warning Signs of Workplace Decision Fatigue

It normally comes after your first caffeine fix of the day.

You feel ready—optimised even—with the same alertness your phone offers after a night-long charge.

You’re brimming with clarity, ready for whatever decisions you’ve got to make.

But as each choice is made, each demand fielded, a little more charge drains away.

You won’t notice the steady drop.

There’s no urgent warning—just a slow, silent slide, much like looking down mid-afternoon and seeing that your battery is nearly empty.

Some ask if decision fatigue is real. But just as the body tires with effort and a lack food and sleep, so does the brain and our ability to make decisions.

What makes decision fatigue so elusive is its quiet approach.

It seldom announces itself loudly.

Instead, it reveals itself through subtle patterns: a few missed details, a touch more hesitation, or the realisation that even simple tasks now require remarkable effort.

By the time you sense something is off, your ‘mental battery’ may already be running low.

How do you know your own mental battery is flagging? Here are the tell-tale signs:

Procrastination and Avoidance:

• You start leaving emails untouched, decisions deferred. That “I’ll deal with it later” habit settles in when the effort of choosing feels heavier than it ought.

Indecision and Delegation:

• Even the smaller choices begin to stick. Options multiply and clarity slips, so you find yourself handing off tasks—not in the spirit of teamwork, but in quiet hope that someone else can spend their charge instead.

Rushed Judgements and Skipped Steps:

• With patience at a premium, process goes out the window. Decisions land quickly, sometimes haphazardly, corners quietly cut in the name of saving precious energy—though errors are the usual reward.

Impulsive Choices:

• Caution is replaced by impulse. Late in the day, you might find yourself saying “yes” or “no” without the usual pause, nudged more by fatigue than reflection.

Dwindling Focus and Motivation:

• The mind drifts. Tasks lose their shape and appeal. You might notice distraction, a brittle mood, or just that ever-present urge to postpone what matters most.

These behaviours are warning signs.

Treat them like a serious weather warning; it’s a invitation to avoid more than a heavy downpour.

Take a break, go for a walk (if it’s not raining), grab a coffee—whatever it takes to help you relieve the drain on your willpower.

There may also be something more fundamental here.

If you’re reading this thinking, this is me everyday, then you’ve got a deeper problem.

Quick Self-Assessment: Are You Experiencing Decision Fatigue?

Lots of leaders overload themselves with decisions.

Circumstance does a great job of feeding fatigue. And let’s face it, work can be an unforgiving environment.

So, what about you?

I’d like to invite you to pause and reflect, and ask yourself these questions. Let’s see if you’re suffering from choice fatigue.

• When during the day do I find my focus fading or decisiveness slipping?
• Are there specific decisions or tasks that consistently leave me feeling drained or uncertain?
• Do I tend to make more impulsive choices as the day progresses?
• How often do I settle for the easiest option rather than the best?
• Which recurring decisions feel like an unnecessary burden on my mental energy?

There is no judgement here.

These reflections help create a clearer picture of how your mental energy ebbs and flows throughout the working day.

Becoming aware of your own patterns is the crucial first step towards managing your capacity effectively.

Awareness offers you an opportunity to change.

By tuning into these early warning signs, you empower yourself to act before fatigue impairs your decision-making.

With greater awareness, you can protect your focus, sharpen your judgement, and maintain steady performance even as the day wears on.

Why Decision Fatigue Never Lets Up at Work

Decision fatigue is a negative daily accumulator.

Every small demand drains your mental energy, making even simple choices feel overwhelming by the end of the day.

There are some obvious—and less obvious drivers—that erode your mental energy.

We are going to explore them, because recognising these is one way to reclaim your cognitive stamina.

The Hidden Cost of Digital Overload

British Telecom used to say, ‘It’s good to talk.’

The telephone has evolved into a domain that has changed the way we communicate with each other.

Now, we are overwhelmed by digital communication.

Digital overload is an incessant flood of information and stimuli that demands your attention and decision-making.

Decisions don’t live in meetings anymore.

They live in emails, notifications, alerts, and social media distractions.

Research shows that the average person checks their phone over 100 times a day, with social media accounting for a significant share of this engagement(Source: Deloitte Mobile Consumer Survey 2023).

Each interaction is a decision.

It could be responding to a message, scrolling through feeds, or deciding whether to post or comment.

These constitute hundreds of micro-decisions. Over time, these raise the cognitive load exponentially, accelerating mental exhaustion.

A 2021 study in the Journal of Occupational Health Psychology found that frequent social media use at work correlates with reduced task focus and increased decision fatigue(Source: J. Occup. Health Psychol., 2021).

This digital overload comes at a cost:

Our minds struggle to filter what’s relevant.

Our emotions struggle to regulate our responses.

How Digital Overload Silently Drains Your Decision-Making Power

This digital overload is relentless.

It forces an unending stream of decisions, pulling your focus in every direction and leaving you mentally exhausted.

Our brains struggle to maintain context amid constant alerts, forcing a rapid reset with every ping.

This fragmented attention builds cognitive overload and saps mental bandwidth.

The result is rising decision fatigue, which directly reduces the quality and accuracy of choices, especially in high-stakes fields like leadership, healthcare, and finance (Stanford University Multitasking Study, 2021).

This mental exhaustion is the hidden enemy of great decision-making.

Understanding how digital distractions sap your cognitive resources is key to reclaiming focus and protecting your most critical decisions.

What Else Sabotages Your Decision-Making Capacity

Digital distractions aren’t the only threat.

Several silent forces at work can quietly drain your mental energy throughout the day.

• Endless Meetings: Back-to-back sessions leave no time for breaks, wearing down mental stamina.
• Role Ambiguity: Shifting priorities and unclear expectations pile on cognitive strain, making every decision that bit harder.
• Sleep Deprivation & Stress: Fatigue chips away at the brain’s executive function, increasing the risk of poor choices and lapses in judgment (Source: Sleep Research Society, 2019).

Together, these factors steadily erode your ability to make clear, confident decisions long before your workday ends.

When Decision Fatigue Takes Over: Why Good Choices Slip Away

Decision fatigue isn’t just exhausting—it leaves your brain running on empty.

Research shows that the constant wave of workplace choices quickly drains glucose in your prefrontal cortex, the area responsible for clear and rational decision-making (Source: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 2011).

As your mental energy drops, your brain starts to lean on mental shortcuts.

That’s when mistakes, decision bias, and snap judgments creep in—often before you even realize it’s happening.

Left unchecked, this cycle fuels errors and impulsive choices, making it harder and harder to lead with clarity and confidence.

When decision fatigue takes hold, even the sharpest professionals start slipping into errors, bias, and impulsive choices.

The daily grind of endless decisions doesn’t just wear you down—it quietly undermines your leadership and business outcomes.

To see exactly how this plays out in real organizations, let’s explore some eye-opening examples of decision fatigue impacting business performance—and what that means for you.

Real-World Examples: Decision Making Fatigue in Business

Decision exhaustion isn’t just an abstract concept — it plays out in offices, clinics, and home workspaces every day, quietly impacting decisions and outcomes.

Executives face long lists of proposals and requests.

Research reveals a clear pattern: the first few submissions receive careful, measured consideration.

But as the meeting wears on, later proposals often get rushed reviews or default rejections.

The brain’s decision-making capacity wanes. Our decision-making biases are more likely to go unchallenged. The potential for impulsive choices rises creating potentially costly oversights.

Healthcare professionals experience it acutely.

Studies show that doctors are more prone to prescribing unnecessary medications during afternoon clinics compared to morning sessions.

As mental capacity drains, so does their ability to weigh complex information, inadvertently increasing risks for patients.

Remote workers encounter a different kind of challenge.

Without the structure of a traditional office, the day becomes punctuated with countless micro-decisions.

• When to check emails?
• How to sequence tasks?
• Which virtual meetings to prioritise?

This continuous low-level decision-making rapidly drains cognitive resources, often before the day’s core work begins.

These examples share a common truth: decision fatigue is a universal challenge, regardless of role or setting.

It creeps in silently, undermining focus, increasing errors, and sapping creativity.

Recognising these signs is the first step — for individuals seeking to protect their willpower, and for organisations aiming to foster resilient, high-performing teams.

How Does Decision Fatigue Impact the Workplace?

Decision fatigue doesn’t just weigh on individuals — its ripple effects spread across teams, projects, and entire organisations. Understanding these impacts is essential for creating workplaces where clarity and productivity thrive.

Productivity Slowdowns and Bottlenecks

When mental energy dwindles, decision-making grinds to a halt. Tasks that once flowed smoothly begin to falter, approvals take longer, and daily progress stalls. Research shows that structured approaches like time blocking can reclaim lost focus — studies reveal remote workers gain nearly 30 extra minutes of productive time per day simply by managing when and how they make decisions.

Increased Errors and Impulsive Choices

Fatigued brains seek shortcuts. This leads to hurried judgements, reliance on defaults, and snap decisions. In critical settings, this surge of impulsivity translates into costly mistakes — from misallocated budgets to overlooked risks and even compromised patient care.

Burnout and Team Misalignment

Decision fatigue is a hidden driver of burnout. When teams lack clear decision-making protocols, energy drains faster. Members expend precious mental resources negotiating who decides what, causing frustration and confusion. Over time, this erodes morale and stymies collaboration.

Why It Matters

The stakes are high. Left unchecked, decision fatigue harms individuals' wellbeing and undermines organisational goals. But by recognising its patterns and impacts, leaders can cultivate environments that preserve mental energy and empower smarter, faster, better decisions.

Five Science-Backed Ways to Beat Decision Fatigue

Decision fatigue is a familiar foe, but it doesn’t have to dictate your day. Implementing effective decision-making steps can protect your cognitive resources and keep your choices clear and consistent throughout the day..

1. Time Block Your Important Work

Reserve your mental prime — usually mornings — for complex, high-stakes decisions. Protect these time blocks fiercely, minimising distractions and deferring less urgent choices until later. Aligning demanding decisions with your peak cognitive energy helps maintain clarity.

2. Manage Digital Distractions, Especially Phone and Social Media Use

Our phones are double-edged swords—tools of connection and productivity, yet also major sources of distraction. The countless pings, notifications, and temptations to check social media consume precious mental energy through constant micro-decisions on whether to engage or scroll. Being mindful about phone usage—setting boundaries like “tech-free” focus periods or limiting social media checks—can preserve your cognitive resources and reduce fatigue.

3. Streamline Repetitive Choices

Automate what you can. Use technology to handle routine tasks like scheduling and email triage. Build checklists that simplify recurring workflows, and reduce the options you face daily. As Barry Schwartz wisely observes, “While some choice is essential, excess options decrease confidence and satisfaction.” Less choice means less mental drain.

4. Use Structured Decision Frameworks

Adopt tools such as the WRAP method or Eisenhower matrix to organise your decision-making. These frameworks guide you through consistent, rational evaluation—counteracting the biases and shortcuts your brain falls into when energy is low.

5. Take (and Normalise!) Strategic Breaks

Breaks aren’t indulgent; they’re essential resets. Short pauses—whether a walk, a mindful moment, or simply sipping water—replenish your mental energy. Encourage a culture that values breaks to sustain focus and resilience across teams.

Next-Level: Creating a Culture of Decisive, Resilient Teams

Adopting the 7 steps of effective problem solving and decision making equips individuals and teams to maintain clarity amidst mental fatigue.

Establish Clear Decision Protocols

When roles and responsibilities are well defined, decisions flow smoothly. Developing and communicating explicit protocols clarifies who decides what—and how. This reduces the cognitive friction caused by uncertainty, freeing teams to focus their energy on the substance of decisions, not the meta-discussions around them.

Encourage Regular Check-Ins and Awareness

Creating space for team members to share how their mental energy is holding up builds collective resilience. Early recognition of fatigue triggers group support and proactive adjustments to workloads or schedules.

Celebrate Systems, Not Just Heroics

Shift recognition from last-minute heroics to reliable processes and shared frameworks. When people see that smart systems sustain performance and wellbeing, adherence and commitment grow. This cultural shift protects both individuals and the organisation from burnout.

Embedding these behaviours and structures creates an environment where decision fatigue is understood, recognised, and managed collectively—enhancing both productivity and employee wellbeing.

Conclusion: Master Decision Fatigue to Unlock Your Best Workday

Every decision you make draws from a finite mental energy reserve. As the day unfolds, this energy diminishes, leaving you vulnerable to poorer choices, lapses in focus, and increased stress.

But decision fatigue is not an unavoidable fate. By understanding its signs, causes, and impacts, and by applying practical strategies, you can safeguard your cognitive capacity and sustain sharp, confident decision-making throughout your busiest days.

Start by protecting your peak mental hours for critical decisions, streamlining routine choices, managing digital distractions thoughtfully, and embracing strategic breaks. Build shared protocols and a supportive culture in your teams to multiply your resilience.

Remember, every choice comes with a cost—even small ones—and being mindful about how you spend your mental energy is a powerful step toward thriving at work and beyond.

Begin today with one small change. Notice how it shifts your clarity, your calm, and your capacity to decide well. With consistent effort and the right systems, your best decisions will not just be possible—they’ll be inevitable.

‍