A circle of competence decides which of your judgements deserve your trust. Inside it, you've seen enough cases and had enough feedback that your instinct is a compressed record of what has worked before. Outside it, the same instinct fires with the same confidence, and nothing stands behind it.
Warren Buffett set out the idea in his 1996 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders. His point was that the size of the circle matters far less than knowing where its edge sits.
That edge is hard to see from the inside. Success in one field builds a general sense of being good at decisions, and that feeling travels with you into rooms where you've never been tested. The more you've achieved, the more convincing it becomes.
So the check has to be deliberate. Before a decision commits real money or time, ask what exactly made you right last time, and whether that thing is present here. If you can't name it, put the decision in one of three piles: inside, outside, or too hard to judge.
The too-hard pile is the most useful of the three. It tells you to borrow a circle that isn't yours, from the colleague, adviser or new hire who has already been right about this kind of call, judged by their record rather than their title.
You only find your own edge from a record of past calls. A decision journal gives you that record, written before the results had a chance to flatter you.
Jill Barad rose from product manager to Mattel's chief executive on the strength of reviving Barbie. In May 1999 she used that same confidence to buy The Learning Company, a software publisher, for $3.5 billion in stock. Software ran on economics a toy marketer had never had to read, and the unit posted a $206 million pre-tax loss for the year.
In February 2000 she resigned, conceding that the unit's problems were "at the root of our disappointing overall performance." That September, Mattel handed it to Gores Technology Group for no cash up front, and Alec Gores put it plainly: "Mattel didn't understand software and software development."